Miss Lilly’s - Bakery Café

Cafe in Newtown

4.9(249 reviews)
98
Hidden Gemi Score

Miss Lilly's Bakery Café receives high praise for its delicious pies, pastries, and desserts, with customers frequently noting the excellent quality of fillings and well-balanced flavors. While most reviews are glowing, some mention occasional issues with burnt pastry and minor complaints about pricing or condiment policies. The owner is described as kind, and the overall experience encourages strong customer loyalty and repeat visits.

Why People Love It

High-quality pie fillings (beef, lamb, chicken, etc.)Excellent pastry texture and balanceDelicious desserts (Sour Cherry Pie, Lemon Curd Cake)Friendly and understanding owner/service
Popular
piespastriesquichescakes

ℹ️ Good to Know

Occasionally burnt pastry

Pricing perceived as steep for some items

📍 Location & Hours

571 King St, Newtown NSW 2042, Australia

(02) 9516 2411

Community Reviews

Find More Gemis Like This

HiddenGemi uses AI to match you with places you'll love - discover your next favorite gemi.